Limited
Impact of Antiretroviral
Therapy on Risk
of Liver-related
Death: The D:A:D
Study
By
Brian Boyle,
MD Antiretroviral
(ARV) therapy
has been highly
effective at
controlling
HIV infection
in many patients,
but concerns
regarding the
potential for
long-term toxicity,
including liver
toxicity,
of this therapy
persist. While
studies performed
to date have
generally indicated
that most ARV
regimens – especially
those that do
not involve
nevirapine
(Viramune),
stavudine
(Zerit)
or high-dose
ritonavir
(Norvir)
– are relatively
unlikely to
cause liver
toxicity, many
of these studies
did not have
enough patients
or long-term
follow-up required
to clearly document
this, especially
in those patients
co-infected
with hepatitis
B (HBV) or C
(HCV). The
investigators
in the D:A:D
study – which
had more than
23,400 HIV-infected
patients who
were prospectively
followed for
over 76,893
person-years
(PY) –assessed
whether an association
exists between
exposure to
ARV therapy
and the risk
of liver-related
deaths (LRD). In
the study, 1248
(5.3%) persons
died (1.6/100
PY) and 183
of these deaths
(15%) were from
liver-related
causes. Among
those with LRD,
16.9% had active
HBV (HBs/eAg+
or HBV DNA+)
and 66.1% HCV
(HCVAb+ or HCV
RNA+) with 7.1%
having both.
97.3% had been
exposed to cART
for a median
of 3.3 years.
The
most frequently
reported immediate
causes of LRD
were hepatic
failure (n=124),
bleeding (38),
infection in
patients with
end stage-liver
disease (21
bacterial/8
opportunistic
infections),
and hepatocellular
carcinoma
(17). The independent
predictors of
LRD were lower
baseline CD4
count (RR 1.18
per two-fold
lower), older
age (RR 1.34
per 5 years
older), intravenous
drug use
(RR 2.49), HCV
(RR 7.30) and
active HBV (RR
3.66) infections.
A
model adjusting
for the risk
factors above
(including the
CD4
count
at study
entry), suggested
a non-significant
trend with >4
years exposure
to ARV therapy
(p=0.23) and
adjustment for
the latest CD4
count strengthened
the relationship
(p=0.03). Stratification
by HCV status
revealed no
significant
relationship
with ARV therapy
exposure and
LRD in either
HCV- or HCV+
patients. The
authors conclude,
“No strong association
was found between
exposure to
[ARV therapy]
for up to 7
years and the
rate of LRD.
When controlling
for the beneficial
effect that
[ARV therapy]
has on the CD4
count, there
was some evidence
of an association
suggesting an
increased risk
of LRD with
extended [ARV
therapy] use.” “However,
the main risk
factors for
LRD were low
CD4 counts,
chronic co-infection
with HBV/HCV
and age.
Additional follow-up
will further
inform whether
[ARV therapy]
(or components
hereof) affects
the risk of
LRD.” 02/07/06 Reference R
Weber and others.
Exposure to
antiretroviral
therapy and
the risk of
liver-related
death: is there
an association?
Results from
the D:A:D Study.
13th
Conference on
Retroviruses
and Opportunistic
Infections.
Denver, CO.
February 5-8,
2006. Abstract
770.
|