Most participants
(83%) were male, with a median age of 48 years. By race/ethnicity, 43% were white,
37% were black, and 15% were Hispanic. Most (84%) had HCV genotype 1; all had
at least mild fibrosis (Metavir stage F1) and 13% had cirrhosis (F4). About one-third
had received previous interferon-based therapy. Most had well-controlled HIV disease,
with a median CD4 cell count of 498 cells/mm3 and about 75% with HIV viral load
below 50 copies/mL.
Treatment
response was assessed at 12 weeks. Those who did not achieve early virological
response (EVR, at least a 2 log drop in HCV RNA) at this point were randomly assigned
to receive maintenance monotherapy with the same dose of pegylated interferon
for 72 weeks or to undergo observation without further treatment. Some 12 week
responders who later relapsed were allowed to roll back into the maintenance therapy
arm, and some additional non-responders who had received similar treatment outside
the trial joined at the start of the maintenance phase. Liver biopsies obtained
before and after treatment were compared for evidence of fibrosis.
Results
At 12 weeks, 56% of patients achieved early
virological response, including 42% who achieved undetectable HCV RNA.
This was higher than the 41% EVR rate previously
seen in another coinfection treatment trial, ACTG 5071, which the researchers
attributed to the higher ribavirin dose used in the present study.
Factors significantly associated with EVR
were genotypes 1 or 4 and white race/ethnicity.
Non-responders were more likely to have genotype
1 (91%), to be black (53%), to have received prior interferon-based treatment
(42%), and to have a lower CD4 count (median 393 cells/mm3) compared with the
original study population as a whole.
86 non-responders were randomized to maintenance
therapy or observation.
In April 2007, the maintenance arm was halted
early after it failed to show any difference in fibrosis progression compared
with the untreated arm.
At this point, 62 patients had completed 72
weeks of follow-up, and 45 paired biopsies were available for analysis.
Among these patients, there was no significant
change in fibrosis in either the pegylated interferon maintenance arm or the untreated
observation arm.
Conclusion
Based
on these findings, the researchers concluded that this randomized controlled trial
"failed to identify significant change" in liver fibrosis in patients
treated with pegylated interferon monotherapy for 72 weeks.
The
study was not able to demonstrate that interferon maintenance reduced fibrosis
progression largely due to the unexpectedly low rate of progression in the observation
group. These results conflict with some prior non-randomized observational studies
that have shown both rapid fibrosis progression among HIV-HCV coinfected people
and slower progression in HCV monoinfected individuals receiving interferon maintenance
therapy. However, as
recently reported, the randomized HALT-C trial of long-term, low-dose Pegasys
maintenance monotherapy in HIV negative individuals failed to demonstrate reduced
fibrosis progression.
Further
controlled studies will be needed to resolve these discrepancies and to determine
the best way to manage both HIV positive and HIV negative people with chronic
hepatitis C who do not achieve sustained response with currently available therapies.
Univ
of Cincinnati, OH; Harvard Sch of Publ Hlth, Boston, MA; Univ of Pittsburgh, PA;
Armed Forces Inst of Pathology, Washington, DC; Beth Israel Deaconess Med Ctr,
Boston, MA; NIAID, NIH, Bethesda, MD; Univ of California, San Francisco, CA; Johns
Hopkins Univ, Baltimore, MD; Massachusetts Gen Hosp, Boston, MA.
2/12/08
Reference K
Sherman, J Andersen, A Butt, and others. Sustained Long-term Antiviral Maintenance
with Pegylated Interferon in HCV/HIV-co-infected Patients: Early Viral Response
and Effect on Fibrosis in Treated and Control Subjects. 15th Conference on Retroviruses
and Opportunistic Infections (CROI). Boston, MA. February 3-6, 2008. Abstract
59.