Notes on the FDA-approved NNRTIs Efavirenz and Nevirapine and a Summary Review
of the Experimental NNRTI Etravirine (TMC125)
TMC125,
currently available for compassionate
use, is a second generation non nucleoside
reverse transcriptase inhibitor
(NNRTI)with
activity in vitro against HIV resistant to older NNRTIs.
It has shown in vivo activity in patients who have developed virologic
failure on NNRTIs and have evidence of genotypic and
phenotypic resistance.
The
NNRTIs, including both efavirenz
(Sustiva) and nevirapine
(Viramune), have intrinsic in vitro activity superior
to all the other classes of antiretroviral agents. Clinical trials including patients
who have been followed now for many years on efavirenz
have demonstrated the durability, as well as potency, of these agents.
Despite
the common misperception to the contrary, efavirenz-containing regimens work equally well or better
than protease inhibitors in individuals with low CD4+ lymphocyte counts and high
viral loads.
Unfortunately,
the NNRTIs' "Achilles heel" is related to the fact that
a single amino acid substitution in reverse transcriptase can result in a high
level (> 1,000 fold) increase in IC50 in vitro and virologic
failure in vivo.
While
in vitro phenotype assays such as those performed by Monogram (formerly ViroLogic)
may suggest that HIV isolated from patients failing nevirapine
(often with the Y181C substitution in RT) would respond to efavirenz,
this is not the case in vivo and cross-resistance between nevirapine,
delavirdine
(Rescriptor), and efavirenz
is essentially complete.
As
an historical aside, this "low genetic barrier to resistance" almost
resulted in efavirenz not being developed. In the late 1980's, Merck identified
a series of compounds commonly known as "L-drugs" (which included
efavirenz). Since Merck studied these drugs primarily
as monotherapy at that time and encountered rapid development
of high- level resistance following initial impressive virologic response, Merck shelved this entire class of drugs
and placed their protease inhibitor, indinavir
(Crixivan), on the front burner (and later insisted
DuPont kill their promising line of cyclic urea protease inhibitors since they
competed with Crixivan).
Fortunately,
individuals including Paul Friedman (who left Merck in 1990 to head Research and
Development at the newly formed joint venture, DuPont Merck Pharmaceutical Company)
believed in this class of agents.
When
Paul asked me to design the Clinical Development Plan and write the initial clinical
study protocols for efavirenz (DMP 266), I insisted
on studying the drug only as part of triple combination
ARV therapy in HIV-infected patients, hence the design of studies -003, 006, and
009, which along with ACTG 164, formed the basis of approval for efavirenz at FDA.
The
following information on TMC125 is drawn from information provided by the Department
of Health and Human Services: TMC125 (etravirine). AIDS Info. September 15, 2006; available
athttp://aidsinfo.nih.gov:
TMC125
is a diarylpyrimidine (DAPY) derivative with nanomolar
range in vitro activity against wild type HIV. Using newer higher-resolution crystal
structures of RT and computer aided
drug design (CADD) techniques, Tibotec chemists designed
a flexible molecule that can fit into the active pocket of RT in different ways
even in the presence of NNRTI resistance substitutions.
TMC125
displays < 5 fold reduction in susceptibility against HIV variants with reduced
susceptibility to first generation NNRTIs. In vitro
testing of more than 1,000 clinical isolates of HIV exhibiting resistance to at
least one currently marketed NNRTI, found that the IC50 of TMC125 was less than
100 nM for 95% of the isolates. The new tablet formulation of
TMC125 has excellent oral bioavailability, is safe and well-tolerated.
In
an open-label Phase IIa trial (C207 Study) of 16 patients infected with 10-500
fold efavirenz resistant virus TMC125 dosed for 7 days
resulted in an approximately 1 log10 reduction in HIV RNA. In the C223 trial,
199 treatment-experienced patients were randomly assigned to receive optimized
background therapy plus TMC125 dosed at either 400 mg or 800 mg BID vs standard-of-care therapy. At 24 weeks, viral load reductions
of 1.04, 1.18, and 0.19 log10 were observed, respectively. Responses were generally
sustained at 48 weeks.
A
small pilot study of 5 heavily ARV pretreated men were treated with twice daily
darunavir 600 mg/ritonavir
100 mg plus TMC125 200 mg twice daily plus optimized nucleoside analog RTI's
plus enfuvirtide. Interim results in the first 4 patients at week
4 showed viral load reductions and CD4 count increases with no development of
PI-associated mutations.
In
drug interaction studies, tipranavir (TPV)/ritonavir
(r) was shown to decrease the AUC of TMC125 by 76%. When coadministered
with darunavir (DRV)/r, AUC of TMC125 was insignificantly
decreased by only 37% and coadministration modestly
increases the levels of DRV. No alterations of methadone PK in the presence of
TMC125 were observed. Bioavailability of TMC125 is not altered by either H2 receptor
antagonists or proton pump inhibitors.
TMC125
appears to be safe and well-tolerated. Analysis of response in clinical trials
to date suggests that TMC125 retains activity in the presence of multiple NNRTI
substitutions where current NNRTIs are not expected
to be effective.
Note:Dean L. Winslow, MD, FACP, is Chief, Division of AIDS Medicine, Santa ClaraValleyMedicalCenter; Clinical Professor
of Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Section Editor, HIV, is Associate
Editor for Infectious Disease Alert.
Dr. Winslow is a consultant for Bayer Diagnostics, and
on the speaker's bureau for GlaxoSmithKline and Pfizer.
01/12/07
Source D L Winslow.TMC125 (Etravirine),
a Second Generation Non-Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitor (Abstract
and Commentary).Infectious Disease Alert: January
1, 2007.
References
K Andries et al. TMC125, a novel next-generation nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor active against
nonnucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor-resistant
human immunodeficiency virus type 1.Antimicrobial
Agents and Chemotherapy 48:4680-4686. 2004.
K
Andries et al. An open-label assessment of TMC125-a new next-generation NNRTI,
for 7 days in HIV-1 infected individuals with NNRTI resistance. AIDS 17:F49-56. 2003.